This Month
Date 22-05-2012
Time 23:42:39

Truth

Explain What Is Religion?

Abstract

Anyone’s religion is the sum of the highest things they care for. But one hopes that what someone cares for will be held on sound principles, and not merely on the pious but dangerous hope called faith.
Page Tags: Care, Coward, Faith, Meaning, Religion, Religious, Word,
Site Tags: Belief Deuteronomic history inquisition Site A-Z Adelphiasophism Truth Christmas sun god Christianity CGText Conjectures Jesus Essene crucifixion argue Hellenization Marduk
Loading
Hell itself is paved with good intentions.
S Bernard of Clairvaux

© Dr M D Magee
Wednesday, 14 October 2009

Religion

What is the meaning of the word religion?

John o’London replied that the popular confusion between religion and Christianity, between religion and particular divisions of faith, between religion and doctrine, and between religion and the churches can be baffling. Christianity may go, faith may faint and fail, doctrine may become rational, churches may fall derelict, their congregations forever dead, but it does not follow that there will be less religion in the world.

While the word is Latin in origin, the Romans did not know whence it came. In modern times, R Graves thought it came from the Latin for “the right thing”, that being what everyone should attend to, to be moral. But the consensus is that it refers to being bound, as by a vow. What was considered binding was someone’s devotion to their god—vows were originally made to gods—and so it remained in its earliest English usage, but, in its true and widest sense, “religion” means simply being bound by, and therefore reverence for, everything held to be sacred, and any manifestation of this feeling. It has to do with belief in something, but it need not be irrational belief or faith, it can be one’s art, principles, society, justice, science, and so on, and it has been used in this sense since before the sixteenth century.

So, what anyone holds for themself to be sacred is their religion, and in so far as they love and persue it, they are religious. The religion of Richard Dawkins is reason, science and evolution, and it is no “religious” slight or insult to him to say it, and nor need he reject this interpretation of it applied to him.

The broader use of the word survives in some of our daily expressions, and, of course, oddly in those which have least connection with divinity. If we say that someone carries out their instructions with “religious care”, or that they take a Turkish bath “religiously” once a week, we are using the word closer to the core of its meaning than when we describe them as religious, meaning he is pious or orthodox or diligent in public worship. In this meaning the word signifies a care or heeding, a persisting zeal—what one would expect from a sincere vow.

Shakespeare again and again uses it thus. In Twelfth Night, Viola has made her exit in a man’s attire:

Sir Toby Belch: A very dishonest paltry boy, and more a coward than a hare.
Fabian: A coward, a most devout coward, and religious in it.

So, also, Henry V says, “My learned lord, we pray you to proceed And justly and religiously unfold Why the law Salique…”.

Jol concluded that we shall disperse much fog when we recognise that anyone’s religion is the sum of the highest things they care for. But one hopes that what someone cares for will be held on sound principles, and not merely on the pious but dangerous hope called faith.


Last uploaded: 20 December, 2010.

Give Us Your Advice on This Page

If you think this page could be improved, give us your advice. You can use various methods:

Other Websites or Blogs

Short Responses and Suggestions

* Required.  No spam




New. No comments posted here yet. Be the first one!

Before you go, think about this…

There are examples of convergence like struthiomimus and the ostrich, ichthyosaurs and whales, and pterosaurs and birds or bats. Convergence at the time of the dinosaurs to solutions which are still suitable today confirms that many evolutionary problems were broadly the same, even though elements of the environment characteristic of today, such as grass, had not emerged in the Cretaceous period. Many of the solutions discovered by the mammals had already been discovered by the dinosaurs before them.
Who Lies Sleeping?

Support Us!
Buy a Book

Support independent publishers and writers snubbed by big retailers.
Ask your public library to order these books.
Available through all good bookshops

Get them cheaper
Direct Order Form
Get them cheaper


© All rights reserved

Who Lies Sleeping?

Who Lies Sleeping?
The Dinosaur Heritage and the Extinction of Man
ISBN 0-9521913-0-X £7.99

The Mystery of Barabbas

The Mystery of Barabbas.
Exploring the Origins of a Pagan Religion
ISBN 0-9521913-1-8 £9.99

The Hidden Jesus

The Hidden Jesus.
The Secret Testament Revealed
ISBN 0-9521913-2-6 £12.99

These pages are for use!

Creative Commons License
This work by Dr M D Magee is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at http://www.askwhy.co.uk/.

This material may be freely used except to make a profit by it! Articles on this website are published and © Mike Magee and AskWhy! Publications except where otherwise attributed. Copyright can be transferred only in writing: Library of Congress: Copyright Basics.

Conditions

Permission to copy for personal use is granted. Teachers and small group facilitators may also make copies for their students and group members, providing that attribution is properly given. When quoting, suggested attribution format:

Author, AskWhy! Publications Website, “Page Title”, Updated: day, month, year, www .askwhy .co .uk / subdomains / page .php

Adding the date accessed also will help future searches when the website no longer exists and has to be accessed from archives… for example…

Dr M D Magee, AskWhy! Publications Website, “Sun Gods as Atoning Saviours” Updated: Monday, May 07, 2001, www.askwhy .co .uk / christianity / 0310sungod .php (accessed 5 August, 2007)

Electronic websites please link to us at http://www.askwhy.co.uk or to major contents pages, if preferred, but we might remove or rename individual pages. Pages may be redisplayed on the web as long as the original source is clear. For commercial permissions apply to AskWhy! Publications.

All rights reserved.
Website Summary

AskWhy! Blogger

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

Add Feed to Google
The Wisdom of Carl
The spontaneous remission rate of all cancers, lumped together, is estimated to be something between one in ten thousand and one in a hundred thousand. If no more than five per cent of the 100 million who have come to Lourdes since 1858 were there to treat their cancers, there should have been something between fifty and 500 cures of cancer from spontaneous remission and therefore seeming miraculous. The total of miraculous cures accepted by the Church is about a hundred, and cancers are only about five percent of them, so the rate of spontaneous remission of cancer at Lourdes seems to be lower than if the patients had stayed at home.
Carl Sagan, The Demon Haunted World (1996)