Misled by Devils, or Just Your Parents? The True God

Abstract

The skeptic, Michael Shermer, asked an audience how many people believed in gods that he named one by one. Not a hand went up for any of them. Everyone there were atheists in respect to these gods. Even if one god did exist and deserved believing, how could anyone know for sure which it is? Christians say their god is the only true one, but a believer in any god could take just the same stance. “Religion and belief in God is socially constructed, historically contingent, and psychologically driven”.

Which is the True God?

Michael Shermer, the noted skeptic, asked an audience he was addressing how many people believed in various gods that he named one by one. Not a hand went up for any of them. He pointed out that all were atheists so far as these gods were concerned. The point he was making was that, if he listed 2500 gods including the Hebrew god of the Jews and Christians, the only one the believers in the audience would accept was their own Hebrew god. He himself did not accept that god either, so he and the audience were within 0.04% of total agreement on atheism.

An internet apologist replied:

So what? For any given truth there may be 2,499 or more similar arguments that are not true. Simply pointing to the 2,499 is meaningless.

That was meant to convince any internet doubters. Yet, even if one of the 2500 gods might exist in some sense and so deserve believing, how can anyone decide objectively which it is? Christians assume their god is the true one and they assume that all other gods are not, but a believer in any other god could take the identically same stance with utter justification. As Shermer concluded, “religion and belief in God is socially constructed, historically contingent, and psychologically driven”.

Our internet auntie replied that “social constructions”, and so on, are not exclusive of divine revelation, missing the point that revelation reveals nothing unless it is certain. We do not know whether any, let alone one of the 2500 deities is the true one, and the fact that we have all been taught father and son, daughter and mother, that a god called Yehouah is the only true one is neither here nor there. Our ancestors might have been misled by devils, or even just humans!

Last uploaded: 04 November, 2009.

Interact

Click and copy the address of this page from your browser’s address bar and safely send it to a friend using email the web.
Considered contributions, criticisms and discussion can be made privately via email [†]
Publication Policy. Interesting general contributions will be listed anonymously, unless the contributor is happy to be named, in the discussion—E-pistle—pages of this website, or if specific to a particular article, on the same webpage, as an addendum to the article.
. E-mail a Comment.
Or, use the AskWhy! Whiteboard, password: “newinaskwhy”

Other Websites or Blogs

God’s Own Summary of the Bible—Magi Mike’s Blog
I explain here in a criticism of a book by F S Collins: “We will see that Christ gave two answers when asked for the most important commandment, and the reason is that the two… ”
Magi Mike’s Blog—http://mikemagee.wordpress.com/.
AskWhy! Blogger at Blogspot.

Short Responses and Suggestions

New. No comments posted here yet. Be the first one!

Before you go, think about this…

An American Nazi of the 1930s was economist Lawrence Dennis, who wrote The Coming American Fascism (1936), a coming which he welcomed. Dennis bemoaned that the resistance to fascism was “liberal norms of law or constitutional guarantees of private rights”, so tried to tried to denigrate traditional liberal Americans as “the laughing stock of their own countrymen”. Maybe his prophesy was of the George W Bush era.